Jason Sudeikis Says Son Otis Is Growing Up in a 'House of Love and Respect' Thanks to Mom Olivia Wilde

Cue the awes: Jason Sudeikis is being an adorable dad, again.

Sudeikis told PEOPLE at the Toronto International Film Festival that his proudest parenting moment is more of an overall accomplishment: he picked the right partner to do it with.

“Just doing it with the right person,” said Sudeikis of fiancée Olivia Wilde. “When I look at Olivia and the way that she pulls off all these things — it’s gonna be easy for him to grow up in a house of love and respect because I feel that way about his mom.”

Want all the latest pregnancy and birth announcements, plus celebrity mom blogs? Click here to get those and more in the PEOPLE Babies newsletter.

The couple shares a 2-year-old son, Otis, and are currently expecting their second child.

On the other hand, the actor, 40, has yet to experience his most embarrassing dad moment, but promised that it’s sure to come.

“I anticipate it and it will be great and I hope it’s captured by professional street photographers,” he joked.

Sudeikis was joined by Colossal costar and fellow new parent Anne Hathaway, 33, who told PEOPLE that she’s easily impressed by son Jonathan, 5 months.

“Aside from the fact that like, we did it, that I birthed him and he birthed me, sticky as that sounds, it’s true,” Hathaway said. “Like every day, every minute he breathes and I’m proud.”

— Lindsay Kimble