Justin Glaze Returns to Bachelor in Paradise to Break Up Eliza Isichei and Rodney Matthews

This post contains spoilers from the latest episode of Bachelor in Paradise.

Justin Glaze returned to the beach on Monday's episode of Bachelor in Paradise — and presented a real Halloween nightmare for Rodney Matthews.

But first, Victoria Fuller needed to decide between Johnny DePhillipo and her new flame, Alex Bordyukov.

"I would love a full opportunity to explore this," Alex, 33, told Victoria, 28.

Victoria seemed open to giving him a chance. "You're just so kind and everything about you is amazing, truly," she told Alex.

RELATED: Bachelor in Paradise Alums Astrid Loch and Kevin Wendt Officially Wed in Dreamy Florida Ceremony

Johnny, 26, already decided to go all in on Victoria. "Watching you with someone else was like, the hardest thing," he said to her. "It's just so hard to see."

Craig Sjodin/Getty, Maarten de Boer/ABC via Getty, Craig Sjodin/Getty

Victoria told Johnny that he thought their time apart "confirms and affirms that what we have is a really good thing, and that you like me."

Going into the rose ceremony, Victoria didn't know who to pick. "If I were to write out what I ever wanted in a husband, it's Alex," she said in an on-camera interview. "I'm so attracted to both."

Jacob Rapini also needed to figure out who might give him a rose. He tried to reconnect Shanae Ankney, with whom he shared a kiss earlier in the season. Jacob, 27, and Shanae, 30, bonded over their love of having clean teeth and they role-played being at the dentist, with Jacob brushing Shanae's teeth with charcoal toothpaste.

ROSE CEREMONY

The women had the roses at the rose ceremony and Serene Russell started off by giving her rose to Brandon Jones. Danielle Maltby followed by extending hers to Michael Allio. Eliza Isichei offered a rose to Rodney and Genevieve Parisi gave one to Aaron Clancy.

Jessenia Cruz asked Andrew Spencer if he'd accept her rose (he did!), Brittany Galvin presented her rose to Tyler Norris and Kate Gallivan offered hers to Logan Palmer.

Craig Sjodin/ABC via Getty, Ricky Middlesworth/ABC via Getty

Shane indeed gave Jacob a rose, and Victoria decided to move forward with Johnny.

But that didn't mean Alex would be going home. Florence Alexandra handed him a rose, meaning Adam Todd said "goodbye."

"I don't want him watching over me," Johnny told the cameras of Alex.

JOHNNY AND VICTORIA'S DATE

Victoria received a date card and asked out Johnny. They proceeded to a special ceremony, where the host asked them to strip down to their bathing suits and share their intentions for the day.

"My intention today is for our relationship to have a new beginning," Victoria said.

Johnny hesitated. "New beginnings for sure," he said.

Victoria noticed Johnny's reluctance to participate and told the cameras, "I personally was all about it. Johnny, on the other hand, was a little more apprehensive." She added how Johnny "has some insecurities that we haven't discussed yet."

The ceremony guide then asked Johnny and Victoria to share their fears.

"I feel like I've always been let down by people and my fears are, I think, being hurt at the end of this," Victoria told Johnny. "I'm just scared because I really like you."

Johnny had similar concerns. "I feel like every time I get close to someone, they disappear on me," he said. "And also, I have a fear that I'm not good enough for you. I feel like I'm not and I really want to be that person for you and I want to grow and do amazing things with you, but I'm afraid I'm not there yet."

Victoria assured, "I think you're there."

Johnny acknowledged, "It's hard to open up and it's hard to be vulnerable for me."

Victoria and Johnny received a blessing at the end of the ceremony and touched based afterwards. "I can see a future with you," Victoria said to Johnny.

To the cameras, Victoria confessed, "I am falling in love with him."

RELATED VIDEO: Bachelor Nation's Hannah Godwin Gives an Update on Wedding Planning with Fiancé Dylan Barbour

JUSTIN ARRIVES ON THE BEACH ONCE MORE

Justin, 28, decided to come back to Paradise because he heard Eliza, 26, showed up after he left. And of course, Justin entered with a date card.

He immediately pulled Eliza to talk and laid out that he returned for her. "I'm so flattered," Eliza said to Justin.

Eliza explained that she'd been talking to Rodney and "didn't think I could see anyone else coming down those steps that I'd be interested in enough to talk to, but then you came."

Justin invited Eliza on the date and she accepted — but she still wanted to let Rodney know. "I want him to say, 'You're mine. Don't go,'" Eliza told the cameras.

Craig Sjodin/ABC; Ricky Middlesworth/ABC via Getty; Craig Sjodin/ABC via Getty

But Rodney took a different stance. "Selfishly, I don't want you to go, but that might be what's best for you to truly gain clarity," he said. "Like, I don't want to be mean about it, rude about it, hypocritical, anything like that."

"I'm not going to fight for someone to be like, 'I want you,'" Eliza told the cameras.

So she proceeded to go to dinner with Justin.

Justin's reappearance caused issues for Genevieve and Aaron, both 27, as well. Aaron recounted to bartender Well Adams how Genevieve started out the show with Justin but when he entered, their stronger connection ultimately won out. Genevieve claimed that wasn't exactly what happened, which then made Aaron feel like a second choice.

"Him coming in today, I guess I just wanted to feel and know that eventually, you would fall in love with me for me," Aaron said. "Not because I'm the guy that made you feel good and he made you feel bad."

"It's you I chose," Genevieve insisted. "It's you because of you, not because of a certain relationship not working."

Aaron explained to Genevieve that he "was really just trying to feel like I was special to you, or you understood me." Genevieve said, "That is so valid."

In an on-camera interview, Genevieve doubled down on her feelings. "I am falling in love with Aaron," she said.

JUSTIN AND ELIZA'S DATE

Eliza started off the night by recounting her conversation with Rodney to Justin.

"I definitely thought that I was in something kind of solid for a minute. You know what I mean?" Eliza said. "I hit it off with Rodney pretty quickly, so it definitely kind of threw me for a loop and I was definitely in my feelings because I think I was just surprised for the response that I got when I kind of breached the topic of, 'Hey, today how do you feel about me going on a date with this other guy that I could potentially really like?'"

Justin said that his first time around "was somewhat similar" and "at certain times, you've just got to put yourself first."

"That's what I want: someone who's intentional, someone who is direct and knows what they want and goes for it," Eliza said. "So I think that's why when you came down tonight and you were just like, no hesitation, just went for it, I was pleasantly surprised because I think that's something I've been missing."

After the sentimental moment, a large bug landed on Justin's arm and he jumped up from the table. Eliza swatted it off.

"You're gorgeous, but for me, it's more than that," Justin said to Eliza, adding that he thinks "there's more than that quiet side" to her.

REALTED: 2 Women Return to Bachelor in Paradise — Only to Learn Their Connections Pursued Other Relationships

Justin asked Eliza what she wanted in a relationship. "I'm super romantic," she said. "I love being pursued." Eliza also shared, "I'm ready to find the person that I want to be with."

"I'm the exact same way," Justin agreed. "I don't want to settle for anything."

The date made Eliza think differently about how she wanted to move forward. "It made me realize that maybe there is a better fit for me and what I need in a partner," she said in an on-camera interview.

Meanwhile, Rodney regretted not telling Eliza how he really felt. "If she comes back tonight and it's Justin for her," he said, "that would break my heart."

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up to date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Bachelor in Paradise airs Mondays and Tuesdays at 8 p.m. ET on ABC.