The best reality shows on Netflix streaming right now (September 2024)
This article contains affiliate links; if you click such a link and make a purchase, Digital Trends and Yahoo Inc. may earn a commission.
Whether you like to admit it or not, everyone loves a good reality show now and then. It might be a drama-fueled dating show, an exciting competition series featuring physical challenges and mental competitions, or players showing off their prowess in cooking, baking, or building. The best reality shows on Netflix right now represent a diverse mix of options.
Netflix offers both its own reality show originals as well as access to popular network reality shows, even if it might only be a season or two. If you’re looking for an entertaining reality show that’s unlike anything else you’ve seen on television, Netflix has you covered. Conversely, if you want a reality show that’s exactly what you expect, there are options in that space, too.
The Mole (2022)
Seasons: 2
Genre: Reality
Cast: Ari Shapiro, Antonio Alejandro Castellanos, Quaylyn
Originally airing from 2001 to 2008 and initially hosted by Anderson Cooper, The Mole returned on Netflix in 2022, and it remains one of the more intelligent reality competition series available today. Players work in groups to add money to a pot, knowing that only one person will eventually emerge as the winner. One player, however, has a different agenda: They’re a secret Mole, tasked with slyly sabotaging the group’s efforts at making money. Players take multiple choice quizzes at the end of every episode, and the person who knows the least about the true identity of the Mole goes home. By the end, the last person standing wins.
The Mole can get intense with cliffhanger endings and tensions rising high as players get suspicious and accusatory of others. What’s particularly fun about The Mole is that unlike similar shows like Peacock’s The Traitors, viewers at home don’t know who The Mole is either, so you can play along, too.
Nailed It! (2018)
Rated: TV-PG
Seasons: 7
Genre: Reality
Cast: Nicole Byer, Jacques Torres
Nailed It! is not your typical baking show. Hosts Nicole Byer and Jacques Torres show amateur bakers complicated dessert creations, which they have a set time to try to replicate. The twist? These bakers aren’t very good. If you’ve ever seen posts and memes online of people posting the image of a cake they were trying to make compared to their atrocious, sometimes even frightening version, that’s exactly what Nailed It! is about. In fact, it was this trend that inspired the show in the first place. How awfully can these bakers mess up the presentation? They aren’t trying to do it on purpose, but there’s a lot of skill and talent that goes into baking and decorating, and not everyone possesses it.
Nailed It! is good for a laugh, thanks to Byer’s hilarious commentary as host, which has earned her two well-deserved Emmy Award nominations for Outstanding Host for a Reality or Competition Program. With seven seasons to date along with three holiday-themed special seasons, there’s a lot of botched baking to take a bite out of. Plus, you’ll feel better about your own failed attempts at a Cookie Monster cake for your kid’s birthday when you see what the terrifying concoction someone else has made. Thankfully, everyone approaches the bakes as good-natured fun and can have a laugh at their baking shortcomings.
Survivor (2000)
Rated: TV-PG
Seasons: 47
Genre: Reality
Cast: Jeff Probst
Created by: Mark Burnett, Charlie Parsons
Survivor is a CBS show that streams on Paramount+. But did you know you can watch two seasons of the iconic reality competition series on Netflix, too? The available seasons include two popular ones. Survivor: Pearl Islands (season 7) features fan-favorite players Rupert Boneham and Sandra Diaz-Twine, and Survivor: Millennials vs. Gen X (season 33), as the name implies, put two generations of players against one another. This season features controversies, players overcoming personal obstacles, fears, and insecurities, and the first full cast evacuation due to extreme weather.
In Survivor, which has been going strong for 46 seasons since 2000, players are left on a remote island to fend for themselves. Given a bag of rice, sometimes flint, and nothing more, they must build shelter, find food, and figure out how to get along. They compete in physically and mentally demanding challenges to win safety for their tribe, then vote one another out one by one until only three people (formerly two) are left to plead their cases to the jury as to why they deserve to win. “Outwit, outplay, outlast” is the show’s tagline, and every player interprets this in their own strategic way. The show has become about so much more, however, as everyone from older housewives to young introverts try their hand at the game and prove to themselves that they can overcome just about anything.
The Circle (2020)
Rated: TV-MA
Seasons: 6
Genre: Reality
Cast: Michelle Buteau
Created by: Tim Harcourt
Described as Catfish meets Big Brother, players in The Circle are in separate apartments where they chat with one another using a large monitor and voice assistant called “Circle.” Fans watch as players audibly dictate their messages, emojis and all, and interact with one another in groups or one-on-one. All they share is a profile with basic information and a single pic. The twist: some people are presenting as who they are and others are “catfishing,” pretending to be someone else. As the competition proceeds, popular players are voted in as “influencers” (or strategically downvoted since they’re viewed as threats) and one person is voted out until only the last five remain. They cast their final rankings as if in Black Mirror‘s Nosedive episode, then meet in person for a reveal of the winner.
Yes, at times The Circle can seem downright boring and monotonous. But once you get into a season and invested in the players and everything going on, you can’t turn it off. What’s more, unlike other competition shows where backstabbing is par for the course, the players on The Circle tend to be supportive of one another instead. It’s all about being liked, right? People who would never likely become friends outside of the game form tight bonds. Some share hardships and personal struggles. It’s refreshing to see a game with young players that highlights the “don’t judge a book by its cover” premise. It’s also tons of fun to see older men playing younger woman, women playing as their husbands or fathers, even once a young man fooling everyone into thinking he was a middle-aged mom. There have even been two Spice Girls (yes, the real ones) playing as a young male author, and in the latest season, an AI computer programmed to converse as a young male.
Love Is Blind (2020)
Rated: TV-MA
Seasons: 6
Genre: Reality
Cast: Nick Lachey, Vanessa Lachey, Amy Cortés
Created by: Chris Coelen
The unconventional dating show that took the streaming world by storm, Love is Blind has singles “meet” in pods where they can have conversations with one another but never see each other in person. They are encouraged not to discuss physical appearance, but to work on building emotional connections. If they decide they have found a soulmate, in a completely backward twist, they can propose then finally meet in person. From there, they begin a whirlwind engagement with a vacation, then living in a shared apartment back home where they plan their pending nuptials.
It all culminates in a final episode each season where couples who make it that far walk down the aisle and either say “I do” or “I don’t.” The experiment has worked with nine successful marriages through the six seasons to date. But there have also been several failed marriages and relationships. There’s plenty of drama to keep you entertained, but also heartwarming stories of people who have found their special someone “sight unseen,” as the show’s tagline reads. Love is Blind is the kind of show that will make you rush to text friends after watching a batch of episodes to hash out the most unbelievably shocking moments. Powered through all six seasons to date? Check out the inaugural season of Love is Blind: UK, which is just as good, if not better, than the American season.
Squid Game: The Challenge (2023)
Rated: TV-14
Seasons: 2
Genre: Reality
Cast: Bryton Constantin
Developed following the tremendous success of the Korean drama Squid Game, Squid Game: The Challenge is a British reality show that isn’t as ominous as the violent and murderous show, but does challenge players to make tough decisions. Some of the same childhood games that appear in the series are replicated for the show (yes, that includes Red Light, Green Light), along with some new ones: think an oversized version of Battleship. While players aren’t actually killed when they’re eliminated, they fight to the paintball-like “death” for the grand prize of $4.56 million, the largest-ever single cash prize in the history of reality TV.
The first season introduced a mix of personalities with players you want to root for and others you can’t wait to see eliminated. The rounds are savage, some people being eliminated abruptly, others the result of someone else’s doing and not their own mistake. A complex social experiment, Squid Game: The Challenge teaches a lot about the human condition. A second season is in the works.
The Great British Bake Off (2017)
Seasons: 7
Genre: Reality
Cast: Paul Hollywood, Prue Leith, Noel Fielding
Created by: Anna Beattie
Also called The Great British Baking Show, this British series has been going strong since 2010. Amateur bakers gather to compete in challenges, hoping to impress the celebrity judges with their skills. Each week has a different theme and three challenges: there’s a signature bake, a technical challenge, and a showstopper. As the bakers furiously work to complete their delectable desserts, the hosts and judges observe and deliver colorful commentary. At the end of each episode, one baker is sent home until the last one standing is crowned the champion.
The series has gone through several hosts and celebrity judges over the last almost 25 years. But The Great British Bake Off remains innovative, tasking competitors with creating desserts with which they may not have had previous experience. They’re usually given minimal instructions for the technical bake, providing an opportunity to really show off their intuition and baking talents. The show is inspiring and filled with personality as competitors include everyone from young men with talents for baking to grandmas who are finally showing off their decades of home cooking experience outside of their own kitchens. In the latest season, fan favorites Paul Hollywood and Prue Leith return as judges.
Love on the Spectrum (2022)
Seasons: 3
Genre: Documentary, Reality
I promise this will be one of the most uplifting shows you have ever watched. A reality dating series like no other, Love on the Spectrum originally hails from Australia. But following the original version’s success on Netflix, an American version was launched as well. The focus is on singles who are on the autism spectrum. While they have trouble in social situations and connecting with others, they seek companionship just like anyone else. Show creator and executive producer Cian O’Clery meets with these singles to help them find love. Through coaching, speed dating events (specifically designed for those on the spectrum), and blind dates, they practice their dating skills and hopefully find someone they would like to continue seeing.
You’ll learn a lot about the autism spectrum from the cast, include how diverse it is in how it presents in different people, as well as how other disabilities can play into the equation as well, from ADHD to dyslexia. The cast is endearing, sweet, and many of them wildly funny as well. While Love on the Spectrum: Australia is arguably the better of the two versions, you can stream the original on Netflix as well. In both cases, the concept is a satisfyingly different take on the cookie-cutter reality dating show, and as feel-good as they come.
